The extent and causes of academic text recycling or ‘self-plagiarism’

Last modified: October 16, 2017

Research article by Serge Horbach and Willem Halffman (Radboud University Nijmegen) in Research Policy

“Among the various forms of academic misconduct, text recycling or ‘self-plagiarism’ holds a particularly contentious position as a new way to game the reward system of science. A recent case of alleged ‘self-plagiarism’ by the prominent Dutch economist Peter Nijkamp has attracted much public and regulatory attention in the Netherlands. During the Nijkamp controversy, it became evident that many questions around text recycling have only partly been answered and that much uncertainty still exists. While the conditions of fair text reuse have been specified more clearly in the wake of this case, the extent and causes of problematic text recycling remain unclear. In this study, we investigated the extent of problematic text recycling in order to obtain understanding of its occurrence in four research areas: biochemistry & molecular biology, economics, history and psychology. We also investigated some potential reasons and motives for authors to recycle their text, by testing current hypotheses in scholarly literature regarding the causes of text recycling. To this end, an analysis was performed on 922 journal articles, using the Turnitin plagiarism detection software, followed by close manual interpretation of the results. We observed considerable levels of problematic text recycling, particularly in economics and psychology, while it became clear that the extent of text recycling varies substantially between research fields. In addition, we found evidence that more productive authors are more likely to recycle their papers. In addition, the analysis provides insight into the influence of the number of authors and the existence of editorial policies on the occurrence of problematic text recycling.” Please read the full article here.

The Dutch newspaper ‘de Volkskrant’ covered the article extensively here, featuring comments by Professor of Methodology and Integrity Lex Bouter of VU University Amsterdam.

Link to full article in Research Policy: https://ac.els-cdn.com/S0048733317301543/1-s2.0-S0048733317301543-main.pdf?_tid=25c2c4f4-b245-11e7-9cf0-00000aab0f02&acdnat=1508139751_339a7eb4ffd2419da1b31deda041d553

Link to article in de Volkskrant: https://www.volkskrant.nl/wetenschap/nederlandse-economen-en-psychologen-plegen-vaak-zelfplagiaat-vooral-prominente-wetenschappers~a4518392/

NRIN devotes a great deal of attention to the website’s content and would greatly appreciate your suggestions of documents or links you believe to belong on this website.

This selection is an incomplete convenience sample, and does not reflect NRIN’s vision or opinion. Including an item does not necessarily mean that we agree with the authors nor does it imply we think unmentioned items are of poorer quality.

Please report any suggestions, inaccuracies or nonfunctioning hyperlinks etc. that you discover. Thanks in advance!

Contact
Icon